Ordered take out. Greek salad supreme and chicken souvlaki on pita. Ordering was easy, pickup was equally as easy except they charge a 4% tariff for using a credit card which irks me. Food was delicious, plentiful and fresh. Really enjoyed the chunks of roasted eggplant and beets in the salad. Used to eat there and order the Greek eggplant but it's not in the menu anymore. They should bring it back. Toasted eggplant with feta and tomato sauce and maybe some Greek spices. Used to be amazing.

Let me start out by saying that I have run 2 Casino Hotels and have a longtime Hospitality background including Family Owned Hotels and Restaurants My wife and daughter and myself have dined at Athena's many times and have throughly enjoyed our dining experience It is our go to Restaurant Simply amazing We love the relaxed and elegant atmosphere with impeccable service The food is second to none Fresh homemade and levels above the competition Pride of ownership shines as the owners friendly greeting you at the door and personally oversee your meal by cooking it themselves The Greek Ceasar salad is creamy and refreshing and. Lows away the traditional Ceasar My daughters absolutely devoured the stuffed grape leaves and oregano chicken My wife loves the pork chop says it's the best she has ever had I love the seafood pasta dish but had the lamb shank tonight It blew me away Try it for yourself guaranteed to impress Our new favorite Restaurant Not just Greek something for everyone BYOB is a bonus I used to dine at the Casinos but no more We can't wait to go back again

Charming family owned restaurant. I have been going here since they opened - about 20 years, now I believe. The food is flavorful and delicious! Also, who doesn't love to have the exact wine that you love - BYOB is the best! And the service is always outstanding. I don't get to go too often anymore since I moved, If I lived in the area still, I would be there probably once a month.

Great food and service. The whole fish is amazing. Clean and in a nice area. Entire menu is good

My family group of 8 people visited for a late lunch. Nobody else was in the restaurant when we arrived. The room was uncomfortably hot when we arrived, but we either quickly got used to it or the A/C was cranked up. We were greeted and served promptly. We ordered various dishes to share, including a generous portion of the "trio of meze" -- with our choice of 3 appetizers. All meze were delicious with warm fresh pitas. We also ordered a gyro plate, Greek salad and an Athenian salad. All were generous and excellent. We were puzzled by the charge for tap water, since in our home state restaurants must provide free water. But this was not a big problem for us. On a sour note, we were charged more than the printed menu price for the meze. The price discrepancy was quickly refunded when we pointed it out. To be fair, I see that the online price is higher than the price on the printed menu. They should update the price on the menu to prevent problems in the future.

Kind of interesting to see the juxtaposition of good/bad reviews here. Either way, I came here twice during my recent vacation in the area (which has a dearth of decent food in the immediate vicinity) - and in both cases we had a fantastic experience. The food itself was excellent. No complaints and the hummus and other dip options we tried as our appetizer were absolutely delicious. They were also very accommodating and kept the (yummy) pita bread coming! We tried several entrees including the Shrimp Alexander, Gyro Platter and also the Greek Salad. Everything was delicious, fresh and very tasty. The service was also very friendly and they were really great to our children which was an added bonus. Generally speaking the entire experience was solid and contrary to some opinions, this is not diner food. I would happily eat here versus some of the mediocre diner food we get up here in northern NJ/NYC. The only blip is they charged for water as they don't serve tap water. I drank soda so that didn't affect me but it did seem weird not to have tap as an option. However, this didn't detract from the overall experience which was favorable in terms of the food, ambiance and service combined. I will definitely be back again the next time I'm in the area.